Nadene Goldfoot
Zoran Mamdami was born in 1991, only 34 years old! He is a politician who has served since 2021 (4 years) as a member of the New York State Assembly from the 36th district, representing the Queens neighborhood of Astoria. A member of the Democratic Party and the Democratic Socialists of America, he is the Democratic nominee for mayor of New York City in the 2025 election. His campaign platform includes support for fare-free city buses, public child care, city-owned grocery stores, LGBTQ rights, a rent freeze on rent-stabilized units, additional affordable housing units, comprehensive public safety reform, and a $30 minimum wage by 2030. Mamdani also supports tax increases on corporations and those earning above $1 million annually.
His mother is a Punjabi Hindu who was born in Rourkela and raised in Bhubaneswar, and his father is a Gujarati Muslim who was born in Bombay and grew up primarily in Uganda, where Mamdami was born as a Muslim.
He is Shia Muslim and identifies with the Twelver branch. This is the state religion of Iran! I feel that by voting for him, it will bring Iran closer than ever, a country out to destroy the USA and Israel. Iran is Israel's enemy, and also the USA's.
Shiism has a complex relationship with Israel, primarily driven by the geopolitical actions of the Iranian-backed Lebanese militant group, Hezbollah. While Shiites are a minority within the global Muslim population, and there is virtually no presence of Shiites in Israel itself, Hezbollah and other factions have historically opposed Israel, leading to increased regional tension. Shias of Iran blame Sunni Islamists for teaching them to hate Israel.
Palestine, whose Muslim population is predominantly Sunni, was thus exclusively a Sunni issue, never a Shia problem, at least until 1979, when Shia firebrand cleric Ruhollah Khomeini came to power in Iran. Khomeini preached a version of militant Shiism that incorporated Muslim Brotherhood doctrines alien to the traditional Shia creed as upheld by Iraq’s Najaf, the Vatican of the Shia world.
Zohran Mamdani, a New York City mayoral candidate, has a long history of strongly pro-Palestinian activism and criticism of Israel. His views include calling Israel's actions in Gaza a genocide and stating he cannot support it as an officially Jewish state, which has drawn both praise and sharp criticism from various communities. His past statements have also faced scrutiny, such as a remark linking the NYPD and the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) during a 2023 speech. Connection to NYPD and IDF: He has explained a 2023 comment linking the NYPD and IDF as a reference to training exercises between the two, though some critics remain concerned about his views on the relationship between the two forces.
- Views on Israel as a Jewish state: Mamdani has stated he would not recognize any state's right to exist based on a system of hierarchy of race or religion, leading to the criticism that he is questioning Israel's right to exist as a Jewish state. (Is he forgetting how many states are listed as Muslim states?)
- Eight Islamic states have adopted Islam as the ideological foundation of state and constitution. There are about 50 that are Muslim majority states. How about Iran? Yes, Iran is a Muslim state, officially a Muslim theocracy whose legal system is based on Islamic law (sharia). Its constitution declares Twelver Ja'afari Shia Islam as the official state religion, and all laws are supposed to be based on Islamic criteria. The government is structured as a religious democracy, combining elected institutions with an unelected supreme leader and a Guardian Council that vets all candidates for public office.
- Israel's actions: He has called Israel's actions in Gaza a genocide and is critical of its treatment of Palestinians.
- Past legislation: In the New York State Assembly, he sponsored the "Not On Our Dime" Act, which aimed to strip tax-exempt status from charities with ties to Israeli settler groups.
- Oh G-d ! This man has the mouth of Iran! So many people have already joined him in this acceptance of nonsense, but he has been first as a Muslim that following Iran's thinking patterns, I'm afraid. This may be why he's running in the first place!
A July 2025 poll indicated a shift in Jewish American political attitudes, with 43% of Jewish New Yorkers and 67% of Jewish voters under 44 planning to support Mamdani — levels of support suggesting waning attachment to traditional pro-Israel politics, while many Jewish leaders and voters remained critical of Mamdani. This is why these Jewish youth especially are Regressive Jews.
They know nothing about Israel and seem to not care about learning at all. They are believing all the misleading anti-Israel news reports from other people other than the Jews themselves. This way, they are getting more social approval from their peers. They are joining them! In a way, they feel ashamed of their Jewish inheritance. I am really disappointed that this is what theyturned out to be.
And why should I care? I'm living in Portland, Oregon, 91, living in Assisted Living, and hold dual citizenship with Israel. What has this election got to do with me? New York has been the center of Jewishsociety since its beginning; creating the acceptance of the Jewish peoplethere. Jews makeup 2% of New York's population, of which we are only 0.02% (2/10 of one%) of the world's population. As they feel and treat Jews in New York soas they will treat Jews in Portland, Oregon. Is it progress these days to follow others like sheep do?
So between his socialistic outlook, and his anti-Israel upbringing, no thankyou in choosing Mamdami in the Mayor election. Here is more informationof how he feels about Israel.
Unlike his opponents in the mayoral race, Mamdani has offered perspectives on Israel, Zionism, and antisemitism that have upset and even alarmed some voters. Although he has never denied that the state of Israel has a right to exist, he simultaneously has not affirmed that it should exist as a Jewish state. Mamdani is forthright in his opposition to Israel’s use of weapons that he calls "violence" against the Palestinian people, and has classified the ongoing war in Gaza as a “genocide.” He also has not swayed from his support for the boycott, divestment, and sanctions movement, which aims to pressure Israel so that the state may comply with international law. When it comes to New York’s institutional ties to Israel, Mamdani wants to deviate from the past practice of the city’s mayors, who supported initiatives such as the NYC-Israel Economic Council and the NYPD’s police exchange programs. Perhaps the most remarkable promise Mamdani has made is to arrest Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu if he ever enters the city.
Instead of marketing himself as an ally to Israel, Mamdani has instead channeled his energy into targeting many of the everyday concerns of Jewish New Yorkers. According to data released by the NYPD, Jews were the primary target of hate crimes reported (hate crimes remain largelyunderreported across the board) in the city in 2024, constituting nearly 54 percent of the hate crimes counted. He has called for increasing funding for hate violence programs from $3 million to $26 million. He has also signified support for the implementation of the “Hidden Voices” program, which would teach students from kindergarten through 12thgrade about Jewish Americans in U.S. history (but teaching them what about Jews?
On the second anniversary of the October 7th attacks, Mamdani released a statement mourning those killed in both Israel and occupied Palestine, and he has repeatedly expressed a continued commitment to condemning antisemitism across the country.
Resource:
https://israel-nadene.blogspot.com/2025/11/they-are-called-progressive-jews-but.html
https://prospect.org/2025/10/30/mamdani-and-the-jews/
https://www.fpri.org/article/2010/05/shiism-what-students-need-to-know/
No comments:
Post a Comment