Showing posts with label Jerusalem. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jerusalem. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 19, 2020

When Greece and Rome Vied For Jerusalem

Nadene Goldfoot                                                                                                               
The House of David ruled Israel with Solomon dying in 920 BCE and his son, Rehoboam (933-917)  taking over.  At the same time, Rehoboam's ruling on taxes followed Solomon's wishes that were not the peoples, and so a split happened and Jeroboam, an Ephraimite, superintendent of forced labor, (933-912) took over the Northern 10 tribes.  They had had a Civil War and remained divided in Israel and Judah.  Israel lost their land and people when  the kingdom of Assyria had attacked them and took away the best they had, including their people in 721 BCE.  This was followed by the the Babylonians who had taken the Assyrians in 597-586 BCE who took the Jews to Babylonia.  Many Babylonian Jews had been freed by King Darius in 538 BCE to return to Jerusalem to rebuild the Temple!  It had been destroyed by King Nebuchadnezzar.  Not all Jews returned.  
                                                                   
           Back  when Greece had become the new powerhouse and took over Judah, the Jewish kings had lost control.  Antiochus was the name of 13 Greek kings of the House of Seleucus who ruled Syria in the Hellenistic Period and it was Antiochus III who reigned from 223 to 187 BCE and was the most involved with Judah.  
                                                       
Babylon with 200,000 population

Antiochus III transferred 2,000 Jewish families from Babylon to Lydia and Phrygia.  These were Jews who had not returned to Jerusalem when others by when King Darius had freed them to return and rebuild the first Temple.   Then he captured Jerusalem in 198 BCE.  Antiochus treated the Jews with some understanding.  
                                                     
    
                                                         

Then along came Antiochus IV Epiphanes who reigned from 175 to 163 BCE.  He was turned back by Rome on his 2nd expedition  against Egypt in 168 BCE and so he occupied Jerusalem, plundered the Temple treasure, and tried to hellenize Judea by force  in order to convert it into a reliable frontier province.   This brought about an uprising which Antiochus suppressed with great cruelty.  Thousands of Jews were killed and many were sold into slavery.  

Antiochus brought in foreign people into Jerusalem and fortified the ACRA (Fortress)  a stronghold of the Hellenizers to dominate the city.  He started a fierce religious persecution of the Jews by forbidding circumcision and observing the Sabbath.

He desecrated the Temple altar and set up pagan altars in the provincial towns, and then compelled the Jews to participate in pagan ceremonies.  
                                                         
Maccabees fighting Greek soldiers

His excesses caused the Hashmonean uprising.  A priest in Jerusalem by the name of Mattathias had a son named Judah.  They were called the Maccabees.  They led this revolt.  They were very brave to do so as Antiochus had large forces of trained soldiers, weapons galore and even war elephants.  All Judah Maccabee had was a small band of followers who were devoted to the Law of G-d through Moses. Judah knew the land of Israel when the Greeks didn't.  The land had twisted hills and valleys, mountains and caves, forests and desert.  There were places where he and his men could hide.  They fought gorrilla-style; hide and reappear suddenly, striking the enemy when least expected.  
                                                       

However, when Judah Maccabee captured Jerusalem in 165 BCE, he failed to  take the Acra.  The fortress continued in Greek occupation until 142 BCE when it was occupied by Simon the Hasmonean,(brother of Judas)  and the Greek garrison and Hellenizers who had escaped there were expelled.   That was enough to give them the miracle of victory over the Greeks. For the first time in history, a people fought a war to gain freedom of religion.   
                                                        

Pope Alexander VI, born Rodrigo de Borja, was Pope from 11 August 1492 until his death in 1503. Born into the prominent Borgia family in Xàtiva in the Crown of Aragon, Rodrigo studied law at the University of Bologna.  This was much later happening In Italy at the time of the
Spanish Inquisition; quite a surprise. Two of Alexander's successors, Sixtus V and Urban VIII, described him as one of the most outstanding popes since Saint Peter even though he was controversial.  

Spanish monarchs Ferdinand and Isabella requested a papal bull establishing an inquisition in Spain in 1478Pope Sixtus IV granted a bull permitting the monarchs to select and appoint two or three priests over forty years of age to act as inquisitors.

Jews were living in Rome by 139 BCE in a Jewish community.   Judah and Rome had close relations, possibly in trading, and then of course, Jewish slaves were brought to Rome and reinforced the Jewish communities already started.  Catacombs show that Jews there came from 12 different communities during this classical period.  Future Popes felt that Jewish "insolence" and influence should be suppressed, but allowed them to worship.  Rome treated Jews better than other places did when they were expelling them.  In Rome, they were treated with a "modicum of humanity." The Pope during the days of the Borgias was  different from Popes later.  They were more like kings. This one even had 2 powerful children.         
Roman Nicea Christian Council 325 CE
Questioning what Christianity was to be about; crushing Judaism

(Christians and Jews wonder today what would have happened if Judaism had been erased at this point in time as the Romans tried to do.  There would have been no Jesus to be followed as he was a Jew  tweaking Judaism, not crushing it as the Romans tried to do.  It would take the Roman Emperors later in their conversion to try again to stamp out Judaism by re-addressing the concept Jesus had brought to them.)
                                                        
Roman soldiers questioning a Jewish man,
one down on ground from brutality to these men
reading Hebrew books 

We remember this occasion today with a holiday we've celebrated ever since; Chanukah.  We have a game we play with a dreidel, a top we spin with letters on it that tells us how we win the pot.  It started with this as a cover-up to fool the Greek soldiers when coming across a few Jews.  They said they were playing this gambling game, but they were really studying the Torah (the 1st 5 books of Moses-now the 1st 5 in the Old Testament)  , something forbidden.  
                                                     

For 100 years, the descendents of Mattathias ruled an independent Jewish state.  This family had produced great, even outstanding soldiers, but alas, they didn't turn out to be such kings.  The century of their rulers were almost wrecking the country of Judah.  

It came to the point where 2 Maccabean princes were in competition to rule.  they realized that their arguments might start a civil war, and that had happened long ago when King Solomon had died and their Israel had divided into North and South-North being Israel and South being Judah.  They fought each other.  Jerusalem stayed with Judah, and it was the land that cared the most for the religion, having Jerusalem so close to influence them.  These two princes looked for someone to choose between them like a wise prophet.  In the end they chose a Roman general who was handy, being in the area.  

The Roman general was indeed a general only, and not so wise.  He ignored both men, had no such good intentions,  and made Eretz Yisrael part of the Roman Empire.   The 2 princes had been terribly naive!  
                                                          

"The Roman army, led by the future Emperor Titus, with Tiberius Julius Alexander as his second-in-command, besieged and conquered the city of Jerusalem, which had been controlled by Judean rebel factions since 66 CE, following the Jerusalem riots of 66, when the Judean provisional government was formed in Jerusalem. "

Independence from foreign nations had only lasted for a century.  It would be more than 2,000 years before the descendants of Jacob  would again be masters of their homeland.   That wasn't the end of their trying, though, before much time went by.                                                          


Rome had become the new powerhouse, ruling Eretz Yisrael and the rest of the Middle East, and would include Britain, most of Europe, and all of North Africa.
Governors of their lands were hardened soldiers with their own goals was making money.  They would steal as much as they could before being transferred to other posts.  One even took gold from the Temple treasury for his own personal use.  When the Jews found out and protested, thousands were massacred.  

The country was in rebellion again.  Tiny Judea (Roman change in name from Judah) challenged this mightiest world's empire.  It was another David and Goliath story.  Of course the Romans weren't ruffled and knew this would be an easy victory.  They were fooled, though, as it turned out to be a 4 year struggle for them that made them as angry as a million bees.  Finally after 4 long years they reached the gates of Jerusalem and surrounded the city.  The Jews kept them at bay for 5 long-enduring months.  
                                                       

On the 9th day of the month of Av ( July-August) on the Jewish calendar in 70 CE, the Roman battering rams smashed through the walls of Jerusalem.  Soon the great 2nd Temple  of Solomon was in flames.  It hadn't been easy on the Jews, either.  They were all starving to death during this period as they were cut off from food supplies.  
                                                       
A few had escaped before the serious closure was complete, but most all were caught inside.  We remember this defeat to this day every year by a fast on this date.  "Tisha B'Av (Hebrewתִּשְׁעָה בְּאָבˈ lit. "the ninth of Av") is an annual fast day in Judaism, on which a number of disasters in Jewish history occurred, primarily the destruction of both Solomon's Temple by the Neo-Babylonian Empire and the Second Temple by the Roman Empire in Jerusalem".  Jews were then taken as slaves for the various bloodthirsty uses Romans had such as the circuses with the lions.
                                                     
     Resource: 
 A Young Person's History of Israel 2nd edition, by David Bamberger
The New Standard Jewish Encyclopedia
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Jerusalem_(70_CE)
https://www.ancient.eu/lydia/
https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/israel/history-11.htm
Netflix, Borgia

                                                




Saturday, May 16, 2020

How Britain Became Anti-Semitic

Nadene Goldfoot   
   
Britain was chosen to rule over Palestine for 30 years with the mandate.  It would end in May 1948, having started May 1918.  Britain had expulsed Jews from their own land in 1290 and hadn't let them back in till 1655!  During that whole time the only Jews allowed in England were physicians, and at that only a few for desperate titled gentlemen.                                                                           

                                                   
1949 after Israel's War of Independence November 29, 1947
to Armistice signed in 1949. 

 Look at these facts:  Jews were an unwanted people constantly thought of as scapegoats.  There existed some Jews who had not wandered all over the face of this earth.
They remained in Palestine.The time had come when other Jews decided to join them because of being tired of attacks.                
                                                      
The League of Nations Council was originally designed to have nine members: the five great powers (BritainFrance, Italy, Japan, and the United States with permanent seats, as well as four temporary rotating members (the first four were BelgiumBrazilGreece, and Spain). However, despite an ardent cross-country campaign by US President Wilson, which eventually contributed to his debilitating stroke, the isolationist Senate failed to ratify the treaty and the United States never officially joined the League. Thus, the Council consisted of eight members until 1922, when two additional small states were added. In 1926 the Council was further increased to fifteen members, including Germany.
 
League of Nations January 16, 1920-April 20, 1946
42 founding members, about 34 pictured here
The territories were governed by mandatory powers, such as the United Kingdom in the case of the Mandate of Palestine


The Covenant of the League of Nations was signed on 28 June 1919 as Part I of the Treaty of Versailles, and it became effective together with the rest of the Treaty on 10 January 1920. The first meeting of the Council of the League took place on 16 January 1920, and the first meeting of Assembly of the League took place on 15 November 1920.

The League of Nations, the world's first try of a United Nations, a world organization of getting the consensus of the world to unite against wars thinking wise heads could prevent them, had decided to choose policemen to oversee Palestine after the First World War.  Enough wars, they they thought.  Britain was selected to police or rule over the country, a country once ruled for 400 years by the Ottoman Empire, a Turkish ruled empire.  The Ottoman Empire had sided with the Axis during WWI, the German-led side of the war and they had lost.  This meant that the Ottoman Empire lost their land to the Allies of the world.  Now it was in their hands; a western people handling Middle-eastern people.  


                                                       
William Shakespeare 1564-1616

The only way people knew anything about Jews was through Shakespeare's rendition with Shylock.  "Shylock is a character in William Shakespeare's play The Merchant of Venice (c. 1600). A Venetian Jewish moneylender, Shylock is the play's principal antagonist. His defeat and conversion to Christianity form the climax of the story." 
                                                      
Shylock After the Trial by John Gilbert (late 19th century)

He's made out to be a very bad person in the play.  Being a money-lender is another story.  Christianity had taken a position of not allowing Jews to make a living in any other way other than the despicable underhanded advocation of being a money-lender, something beneath Christian society.  Jews couldn't own land, couldn't farm, so had this as a profession along with peddling.  

Joshua leading former slaves into Canaan (now Palestine)
Moses started with 603,550 people.
They lost 1,820 after 40 years of travel
The world's 1st Israel was settled by 601,730 Jewish slaves of Egypt led by Moses to the Promised Land which was actually Canaan, the land their forefather, Jacob and his band of 70 had left during a famine.    This happened over 3,000 years ago.  It took them 40 years to reach it.

Obstacles like lions and persuasive women tantalizing the men to stop,  and hostile people they encountered,  made the trip dangerous.  Feeding this many was also a problem so they were given Manna to eat.  

In 1948, Israel was born again in the same land, now called Palestine, named by the Romans for the Jews' enemy, the Philistines, with a population of 650,000 Jews.  They also had a great need to possess their own homeland after 3,000 years of wandering.  
                                                        


Do you see why we love our Torah?  How did this happen that Israel had broken apart when King Solomon died into 2 parts;  Israel of the north and Judah of the south,  only to come together again and go through a tough rebirth on May 14, 1948?  The only problem was the the map didn't give the Jews their original Judea and Samaria!  This was called the West Bank by Jordan.  
 
Herzl, 1860-1904

The Twentieth Century was a turn-around for Jews.  In 1897, Theodor Herzl, Hungarian newspaper reporter,  organized in Basle, Switzerland, the 1st Zionist Congress and founded the World Zionist Organization.  (Zion is another name for Jerusalem and for the entire land.)  Zionism came about as an answer to severe events of continued oppression and outbreaks of persecution (pogroms) in Eastern Europe within severe Jewish poverty.  The goal was the return of Jews to the Land and the revival in it of Jewish national iffe; socially, culturally, economically and politically.  As we say during Purim (Passover): Enough already!  Jews started returning.  

King Hussein of the Hejaz, wrote: "We saw the Jews....streaming to Palestine from Russia, Germany, Austria, Spain, America....The cause of causes could not escape those who had the gift of deeper insight;  they knew that the country was for its original sons, for all their differences, a sacred and beloved homeland."  (Al qibla, Mecca, #183,  23 March 1918.  George Antonius, ARAB AWAKENING, p. 269.)

                                           World War I-1914-1918 
                                  A War between the Allies and the Axis
                                                             
Allenby entering Jerusalem during WWI

The British succeeded in capturing BeershebaJaffa, and Jerusalem from October to December 1917. His forces occupied the Jordan Valley during the summer of 1918, then went on to capture northern Palestine and defeat the Ottoman Yildirim Army Group's Eighth Army at the Battle of Megiddo, forcing the Fourth and Seventh Army to retreat towards Damascus. Subsequently, the EEF Pursuit by Desert Mounted Corps captured Damascus and advanced into northern Syria.
This is why the Brits were given the 30 year mandate to rule.  



"On November 2, 1917, the British Balfour Declaration promised to support the establishment of a Jewish national home in Ottoman-controlled Palestine in this letter to Lord Rothschild
                
"His majesty's Government view with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people."  
                                     
                                      Lord Balfour, Foreign Secretary of Great Britain
                                      November 2, 1917
                                 France, Italy and USA officially agreed.  

This was in order to win Jewish support for Britain's First World War effort which was already baled out by the Jewish chemist,  Chaim Weizmann, who created  a special ammunition more powerful than others had for England which won the war for the allies.  The British had also made a promise to the Arabs that a united Arab country, covering most of the Arab Middle East, would result if the Ottoman Turks were defeated.  The Brits broke their promises to both the Jews and the Arabs.  
                                                               
HANDOUT/AFP 
Britain was at war.  Balfour's Declaration gave Jews reason to support them as they were supporting the Jews.  Britain also needed Arab support because Arabs made up more than half the population of the Ottoman Empire.  Britain put themselves in a jackpot by making two opposite promises to these two people. 
The Declaration was approved by the British cabinet and was given to Lord Walter Rothschild to convey it to the Zionist Federation.  It was approved by other Allied governments and incorporated in the Mandate in 1922.   

The 30 year mandate had a hook in it.  The Brits were to help the Jews to create their Jewish Homeland in those 30 years.  That was the promise of the League of Nations.  This hadn't been easy to come by.  It took many meetings of the Jewish leaders  like Chaim Weizmann, Nahum Sokolow and others after WWI had started to make contact with the allies to gain such a position.  They had seen a window with possibilities of opening for them after going for 2,000 years without a country for their people.  Yes, they were a people; not just a religion.  They had their own culture, language, family ties and their own religion.  They would have been a proselytizing religion had they not been prevented from doing so by the Roman Christian emperors.  They had once been an empire as well.  They were the only ancient Middle Eastern people who still existed.  
                                                             
1929 massacres In 1929, Husseini and his associates fomented a violent jihad as they called upon Muslims to “defend” their holy places from the Jews. As a result, pogroms were carried out across Palestine. Arab villagers sympathetic to Jews were often targets of murderous attacks by their Arab brethren as well. British forces were sharply criticized for not policing the territory adequately, for sympathizing with the Arabs, and for standing by and allowing havoc to be wreaked upon Jewish communities in Palestine.
Right after the war in 1921 the Arabs rioted against the Jews mostly in Jerusalem and Safed.  The 1st British High Commissioner for Palestine was Sir Herbert Samuel, an English reformed Jew.  He had kept pretty good law and order, but he left in 1925.  Then the British favoritism for the Arabs was more apparent.  By 1929, Arabs were led by  Haj Amin al-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem,  and rioted in Jerusalem, Hebron and Safed with longer and brutal killings by attacking the unarmed in these cities.  133 Jews were massacred.  Over 200 were wounded.  Jewish property was destroyed.  

The Brits did nothing to punish rioters or prevent more riots.  Violence was the worst in 1936 when Germany was undergoing attacks on Jews.  The Jews in Hebron, a holy city to Jews where Abraham buried his wife, Sarah and one of the cities of cited as a city of refuge as well as once being King David's capital, were
driven out or killed.  After 1,000 years, Hebron had no Jews living there.

The Brits then did a terrible thing.  In 1939, Great Britain issued their "White Paper", stating that England intended to set up an independent state in Palestine in 10 years with a permanent Arab majority.  They were there to be setting up the Jewish Homeland!  This was truly a double-cross.  In 1939 Germany was invading Poland!  Jews had been suffering greatly in the last 3 years in Germany.  My own uncle got out of Germany in May 1939 and may have been the last Jew to do so as the doors closed on them after that.  The Germans had them all as captives, and the doors of Auschwitz were already open-my uncle had been in there!  

The White Paper went on to announce that Jewish immigration would be cut back to 15,000 per year for 5 years;  Then NO MORE Jewish immigrants in Palestine by 1944.  Starting then, land sales to Jews would be restricted or forbidden.  This policy guided British policy behavior in the coming years.  It was the same old anti-Semitism Jews had been enduring for the past 2,000 years!  The Brits had completely turned around 180 degrees in their original responsibility from the world's nations in developing the Jewish Homeland.  The Brit responsible for the White Paper was Neville Chamberlain, who was scared off by the riots from 36 to 39, and he was the  Prime Minister of the United Kingdom from May 1937 to May 1940. He is best known for his foreign policy of appeasement. He is well-known for trusting the Germans not to invade Europe.  
                             
                               Under Ottoman Empire

1880:  saw 25,000 Jews immigrate to Palestine
The first aliya  between 1882 and 1903, brought 20,000 to 30,000 Russians fleeing Czarist Russia’s pogroms. 
Between 1903 and 1914, during the second aliya, 35,000-40,000 more Russians, most of them socialists, established themselves in Palestine.

 The newcomers were very active in the building of Tel-Aviv and also founded kibbutzim (collective villages).  

On the eve of WWI  1914, the 80,000 Jews of Palestine constituted only a tenth of the country’s total population.

 Moreover, Jewish immigration to Palestine constituted only 3 percent of the transoceanic Jewish migration during that period. By way of comparison, of the 2,367,000 Jews who left Europe then, 2,022,000 established themselves in the US.  
Why?  Palestine was made of deserts, swamps, flies, mosquitoes, malaria and weeds and Turkish police.
           USA was paved with gold and democracy and freedom. 

1914-1918: With WWI and the subsequent famine, Palestine’s total population dropped. Its Jewish community now numbered only  60,000.  

By the end of 1931, 174,600 Jews were living in Palestine, 17 percent of the population. 

By 1948 when Israel was pronounced a state among other nations, the Arab states expelled their Jewish subjects in anger.  Entire Jewish communities were without a country so came home to the new Israel, 
including 121,000 out of 130,000 of the Jews in Iraq,
44,000 of out 45,000 of the Jews of Yemen,
30,500 out of 35,000 of the Jews of Libya, 
165,000 Jews came from Morocco, Tunisia, Poland and others from 1955-1957.
Between 1961-1964, 215,056 Jews came mostly from Eastern Europe and North Africa.  
Since the miracle of 1967's War, Israel had a new wave of immigration from North and South America, Western Europe and the Soviet Union.  
Almost 700,000 immigrants had arrived in Israel, almost half the total, came as destitute refugees from Moslem countries.  
The number matches that of the Palestinian Arabs who became refugees in 1948.

WWII and 6,000,000 Jews were murdered in the Holocaust

1956:  1,872,400    Population grew in Israel 
1968   2,841,100
1972: 3,164,000 when 200,000 immigrants had arrived.  
2020: 9,152,000 population with 20+% Arabs.  


Resource:
A Young Person's History of Israel 2nd edition by David Bamberger
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shylock
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/League_of_Nations
The New Standard Jewish Encyclopedia-White Paper
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edmund_Allenby,_1st_Viscount_Allenby
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Paper_of_1939
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neville_Chamberlain
facts about israel, division of information, ministry for foreign affairs, Jerusalem
https://www.cjpme.org/fs_181  immigration years, numbers from Canada research
https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-britain-s-true-motivation-behind-the-balfour-declaration-1.5462518

Tuesday, March 24, 2020

Listen to Who? Ari Shavit of My Promised Land, a Leftist published in 2013 or Dan Kurzman of Genesis 1948 published in 1970

Nadene Goldfoot                                                     
Ari Shavit
                                   
Dan Kurzman



















Never before have I ever encountered such tripe about Israel when I started reading Ari Shavit's Chapter 5 in "My Promised Land" titled Lydda, 1948, and then getting into Safed's entrance into his book, a city I lived in from 1981 to the end of 1985.  It caused me to go back and use the reference material hopefully found in Dan Kurzman's "Genesis 1948"-an American journalist and writer of military history books, who  In the early 1950s,  worked in Europe and in Israel for American newspapers and news agencies and was then correspondent of the NBC News in Jerusalem. to see how he described events in Israel's beginnings in 1948.  Oh yes, Kurzman had tons to say about Lydda.  I certainly hoped that Shavit didn't find his information in Kurzman's book.  I have to confess that I've only read over and over about my 3rd cousin, Stanley Goldfoot in Kurzman's book.  It's so thick that I did not dare start reading it as a text book about the beginnings of Israel.  I had enough other information for that in more concise readings such as "Facts About Israel from Jerusalem's Ministry for Foreign Affairs.  We forget that the mind of the writer can color facts and writers use that knowledge to sway readers one way or the other towards a subject.  It takes talent to write journalistically about history without leading the reader to the left or right.  


As Wikipedia put it, "Ari Shavit (Hebrewארי שביט; born November 26, 1957) is an Israeli reporter and writer. Shavit was a Senior Correspondent at the left-of-center Israeli newspaper Haaretz before he resigned when a pattern of sexual misconduct came to public attention.
A self-described left-wing journalist and anti-occupation peacenik, Shavit is the author of the 2013 New York Times Best Seller My Promised Land: The Triumph and Tragedy of Israel, " the book that puts me into distress.  I could tell at my distress point that Ari had turned against Israel, finding Israel as if he just stumbled into it as if in a time machine, not understanding what was going on at all but finding Israel completely in the wrong.  How he must have hated his ancestors who he wrote about, British Jewish Zionists, who came to Palestine early on in 1897, for landing there, and how they must have turned over in their graves knowing what misconceptions he was pouring into his writing for Israel. Of course the reason I am upset by what little so far I have read is knowing the truth about Israel after living there over 5 years as well as knowing the people and our religion and what it teaches us and has shaped us to live by. I just know that the writer, Ari, has had none of these guidelines to write such as he has.  Age definitely has a lot to do with it as he's only 3 years younger than my daughter. As an Israeli, people put trust in his writings.  That's the deplorable part of his writing.  He seems to not have pride in his people.       

 If anything, it would match other material I already have such as my overused softback of FROM TIME IMMEMORIAL by Joan Peters in 1984, an American reporter who went to original sources originally on the side of the Arabs but who did a 180 after gathering this real information, Battleground, Fact and Fantasy in 1973 by Samuel Katz-author of more than twenty books and one hundred articles on Middle East security issues, terrorism, and police and military special operations. The founder of Special Operations Report, he has appeared as an expert on networks ranging from BBC World News to Fox News to Al JazeeraMyths and Facts-A Concise Record of the Arab-Israeli Conflict by Mitchell G. Bard and Joel Himelfarb in 1984,  

The tragedy is that this former soldier who served in the elite paratrooper brigade of the IDF had lived in fear of the demise of Israel during his whole childhood.  He had developed no hope for Israel in his home which so many Israelis did have through our ancient religion. Where is his faith?  
                                                   
Getting out of Lydda before the Jews come, 1948

Lydda is in my Jewish Encyclopedia..  In Hebrew, it is Lod, a town in Israel that goes back to Egyptian documents and is even mentioned in Chron. 8:12 saying it was built by the tribe of Benjamin!  This is where Israel's airport was built outside of Tel Aviv.  Most of its Arab inhabitant left when the town was captured by the Israeli army in 1948.  This is what Ari and Dan both write about and I think will show a big difference in their telling because of their different perspectives of the capturing.  Of course, since 1948, large numbers of immigrants have settled there.  In 1990 the population was 41,300 and that included 8,400 non-Jews.  
                                                               
City of Lod (Lydda) with mosque and minaret

Kurzman writes about the war against the Jews living in Palestine that took place before the British pulled out.  The Brits had been there for 30 years holding the mandate over the population before the Jews declared the land as Israel on May 14, 1948.  This Arab-Israeli war lasted from November 1947 to March 1949.  Jews had been waiting for over 2,000 years being dispersed in the world.  It's been over 7 decades since then, and fighting is still going on.  Even the corona virus has become ammunition for the Arabs to blame the Jews today. The way they have been telling it, Jews cause everything from bad weather to crops failing.  

Shavit had a good beginning, too, of valuable information.  Then I became stunned in chapter 5 and Lydda.  

My opinion is that everyone not Jewish is prejudice of Jews with a few exceptions,  and has been since even before Christianity started, but of course, became even more so afterwards what with the Roman Empire converting.  England was even more so, showing it by expulsing Jews from their land for 400 years from  1290 to 1655.  They're the ones decided by the League of Nations to hold the 30 year mandate on Palestine and to help them form their Jewish National Home that they all decided Jews should have.   The United Nations replaced the League of Nations, and after waiting for so long and almost being totally wiped out, and losing 80% of promised land, Israel came into being but was attacked 5 minutes after the pronouncement. In 1952, the English attitude towards Jews was that they certainly didn't want any marrying into their families.  That's probably why they didn't mind leaving them without defense tools when they pulled out-completely unlike the promise they had taken to help them create their Jewish homeland.  

This prejudice of a people who differed from others by not being Christians and resisting pressure to convert had brought on through the ages, expulsions, pogroms, forced conversions, murder of Jews, mob attacks,  crusade murderings, slavery, Poland's 1848 massacre of 100,000 Jews, and then the Holocaust of WWII killing 6 million.  Prejudice against Jews has existed for the past 3,000 years like colds, and all the different viruses that visit us seasonally and have been forever since biblical days.  Prejudice is a disease.  Why haven't we given in as a people?  We were told that we were selected because we were stiff-necked, and we promised not to.  Stiff-necked people try their best to keep their promise.  We keep it because we see the truth in it.  We don't want to lose this special vision.

So just what happened in 1948 when every Arab was against us for returning home after a lapse of our large community?  We had Jews living there continuously, but not as a nation; not after the Ottoman Empire had held it for 400 years letting it go to rot, swamp and mosquitoes.  They had made the mistake of siding with the Germans in WWI and losing it to the Allies.  The Jews saw their chance and held hundreds of meetings with the Allies before the war ended and as the Russians had been holding pogrom after pogrom against them, and the French were picking on them again blaming a Jewish Captain in their army for things he had not done and putting him on Devil's Israel, worse prison in the world.  
                                                      
A scandal that rocked France in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the Dreyfus affair involved a Jewish artillery captain in the French army, Alfred Dreyfus (1859-1935), who was falsely convicted of passing military secrets to the Germans, anti-Semitism in the service.  

That was the Dreyfus Affair, that turned out to be the writing on the wall of things to come to Jews.  Just what do you think was building up in some of our Jewish men?  For Jewish men 3,000 years ago were valiant and muscular soldiers, Samsons in the making, fighters for King David.  They had become biblical commentators and mathematicians, traders and rabbis, with no nation to fight for that was theirs, and they've had to quickly leave gas chambers and starvation to pick up a rifle and defend their new country.  
                                                         
Lieutenant-General Sir John Bagot GlubbKCBCMGDSOOBEMCKStJKPM (16 April 1897 – 17 March 1986), known as Glubb Pasha
 

Lydda:  At the time Jordan was called Transjordan.  The capital was Amman, like today.  Glubb Pasha, an Englishman -was a British soldier, scholar and author, who led and trained Transjordan's Arab Legion between 1939 and 1956 as its commanding general.,  was with the Arab Legion and had lost many men and many were wounded and they had no replacements.  So Glubb told their Prime Minister Tawfiq Pasha that they couldn't keep fighting because Transjordan had little to gain as they controlled all the land they wanted (they took 80% of the Jewish land with England's blessing).  If the war started up again they might lose land.  This was thought out during a truce that started on June 11, 1948.  His greatest worry, however, was about Lydda and Ramle which were only 15 miles from Tel Aviv and almost surrounded by Jewish colonies, but had been awarded to the Arabs under the UN partition plan.  Glubb warned the King and PM that they could not be defended.  Both the king and Tawfiq had neglected to send military governors to these 2 places like they did for Hebron, Jerusalem, Ramallah and Nablus.  The Arabs had decided against anymore fighting, and no more money for soldiers.  
                                                         
The siege of Jerusalem 
As it was, the Jews had accepted the original partition plan and the Arabs had tried to scuttle it by force.  Israel felt justified in seeking to improve the original borders.  At first, Israeli defenders had miraculously held out against the regular armies of the Arab world.  They lost Mishmar Hayarden, Yad Mordechai, Nitzanim, the Jewish Quarter in the Old City of Jerusalem and some outposts around Jerusalem.  The Israelis had fought to the breaking point.  The fighting units were worn out with 100 dead in every battalion.  On the Jenin front they were under continuous artillery fire and attacks from the air.  

Hafez Abu Kuwaik, mukhtar of northern Lydda, age 51, grabbed a WWII rifle and joined the town's 300 full-time defenders who were poorly trained, and thought the Arab Legion would come to defend themselves before the Israeli forces would come.  
                                                      


Yitzhak Sadeh (1890 – 1952), commander of the Palmas, one of the founders of the Israel Defense Forces at the time of the establishment of the State of Israel. 

Born in Lublin, Poland, Sadeh began his military career in the Russian army during the First World War. He was decorated for bravery and rose to be a battalion commander. He emigrated to Erez Israel in 1920, upon hearing of the death of Joseph Trumpeldor, whom he had met three years earlier.
- Image ID: MR762G
Yitzhak Sadeh's 8th Armored Brigade had taken a number of Arab villages and Lydda Airport that was bogged down in a struggle near Beit Nahada with Glubb's armored cars.  This pincer operation had Lydda and Ramle practically surrounded.  (I taught in Safed's jr high with a Ned Sadeh.  I wonder if he was related?  Sadeh meant "field." )  Ned had to report to duty even though he was an American.  My husband, a former USA Airforce Airman, had such a bad lung condition that Israel left him alone as a teacher.   
                                                       

 In 1977, following the election of Menachem Begin as Prime Minister, Dayan was expelled from the Labor Party because he joined the Likud-led government as Foreign Minister, playing an important part in negotiating the peace treaty between Egypt and Israel.     

1948 is when Moshe Dayan lost his eye, serving under Sadeh.  With his column going into Beit Shemen welcomed by the village population,  they stormed through Lydda while shooting, leaving Arabs killed.  The driver of the jeep turned the wrong way and they continued, storming into Ramle as their brakes failed.  They entered through a hail of bullets and grenades.  Realizing they were in the wrong city, they raced back to Lydda while suffering more casualties.  
Sadeh was angry that they had left on their own and attacked Lydda.
                                                            
Moshe Dayan (Hebrewמשה דיין‎; 20 May 1915 – 16 October 1981) was an Israeli military leader and politician. As commander of the Jerusalem front in the 1948 Arab–Israeli Warchief of staff of the Israel Defense Forces (1953–58) during the 1956 Suez Crisis, but mainly as Defense Minister during the Six-Day War in 1967, he became to the world a fighting symbol of the new state of Israel.
Shavit calls Israel's soldiers "the training group boys" and has them marching on Lydda on July 11, 1948.  About Dayan, he writes that "after Dayan's storm of fire breaks Lydda's spirit of resistance",....   poetic but really doesn't describe the action.     ...".They lead the long procession of Lydda's inhabitants, their hands in the air, to the Great Mosque and confined them there, thousands of men, young and old.  They hear the shrieking, the howling, the weeping.  They see the horror in the eyes of women and children."   There were no 'thousands', and he doesn't mention Dayan's missing eye that hasn't been to a first aid station as  yet. I imagine the mosque was a normal-size mosque and not such a great one at that.         

The Jews went through hell in fighting for their promised land.  They had few guns, and it took a miracle to come out the winner.  I don't appreciate a one-sided story painting the Jews as the bad guys when it doesn't fit the facts.  

There were 1,339,763 non-Jews in Palestine in 1946 according to reference McCarthy.  According to Ottoman statistics studied by Justin McCarthy, the population of Palestine in the early 19th century was 350,000, in 1860 it was 411,000 and in 1900 about 600,000 of which 94% were Arabs. In 1914 Palestine had a population of 657,000 Muslim Arabs, 81,000 Christian Arabs, and 59,000 Jews. McCarthy estimates the non-Jewish population of Palestine at 452,789 in 1882, 737,389 in 1914, 725,507 in 1922, 880,746 in 1931 and 1,339,763 in 1946.

In 1920, the British Government's Interim Report on the Civil Administration of Palestine stated that there were hardly 700,000 people living in Palestine:.
Jewish immigrants went to Palestine and in the 1920s most came from Eastern Europe, land of Pogroms and being forced to live in the Pale of Settlement.  In the 1930s any Jews who could escaped to Palestine from Nazi Germany.  By 1948, the Yishuv (the Jewish community of Israel) numbered 850,000 Jews.  Defense organizations like the Haganah and Irgun formed. 
                                                 
Stanley Goldfoot with his first wife and daughters,
probably at the beach in Tel Aviv.  
My 3rd cousin, Stanley Goldfoot, journalist, also wrote about Israel in his famous "LETTER TO THE WORLD" in a right-sided essay about the world's anti-Semitism towards Jews and why Israel was so important. He was the Stern Group's Chief of Intelligence and had moved to Israel at age 18 from South Africa.  He had lots of pride for his people and knew of the injustice they had suffered throughout history.  Stanley lived in Jerusalem and I was privileged to be able to meet him at the King David Hotel and get to know him. He was a man my mother's age.  Dan Kurzman wrote about him in Genesis 1948.    https://israelseen.com/2014/05/09/1969-stanley-goldfoots-open-letter-to-the-world-from-jerusalem-4/

That was it;  Israel started off with 850,000 Jews who needed a country of their own badly.   They were the remnant of well over 6 million Jews. They were surrounded by millions of hostile Arabs.  The odds have always been against the Jews.   
Update 3/26/2020: I've continued reading the book and feel that the author had been listening more to our Arab population than he had the old Jewish Israeli ones in chpt 5. I've heard such exaggerations from an Arab population at Reed College in Portland  during a gathering about Israel.   The book becomes a better read as I have continued reading. 

Update 3/27/2020: page 166, Ari is telling us that the children in Israel don't want to hear their holocaust parents tell their sad stories-they just want to enjoy life and believe in what their schooling tells them, like that they are strong now, the very best and will not be taken by lambs to the slaughter, and what they will grow up to be and will overcome the Germans and the Arabs and the barren desert.  Then his Freudian slip enters his writing.  "We will overcome our weakness and deformed genes and shameful history."
   You could knock me over with a shotgun;  all the disbeliefs that I have for our history and our people.  Weakness?  What is that-a belief in one G-d only?  We have IQs at least 10 points higher than the rest of humanity and have produced more nobel winners with our stiff-necked thinking.  Deformed genes?  I am so proud to have genes that go back to a Rabbi Samson Wertheimer who was born in 1658 who was a direct descendant of RASHI who was a descendant of King David, genes that made up those nobel winners and people like Albert Einstein who had the highest recorded IQ of 180 who developed the theory of relativity, genes that we share with the Davidic dynasty of kings David and king Solomon, and overcome our shameful history?  

Our history makes up the Old Testament, the bible of both Jews and Christians, which lays down the laws for humanity to follow in order to be humane.  Moses gave us such laws from G-d that people are still in awe of them almost 4,000 years later.  We have so much as a nation to be proud of and yet I see someone who is a self-hating Jew who is apologizing for who he is.  Sad, yes, sad indeed.  Ari, you are not seeing us and our ancestors with the eyes I hoped all Jews would see with but eyes of an anti-Semite. 

 It is because of anti-Semitism that we have been treated so badly by humanity, and this has stemmed from what I call "jealousy."  Jealousy because we could write and read and do sums and kings and queens needed our help occasionally causing us to be invited into their country,  jealousy because we were the "chosen" people of the bible.  All this turning against us caused us to grow into who we are today, surprisingly.  It's as if the cook decided to stir up a cake and threw everything into the batter, over-cooked it, made a mess of it and yet it turned out to be delicious.  We're the cake and G-d was the cook who knew what he was doing.  

Resource:
https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/authors/2111379/samuel-katz
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_history_of_Palestine_(region)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Kurzman
The New Standard Jewish Encyclopedia
https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/yitzhak-sadeh
Read this one: example of being fair and rightous, whether left or right;    https://israel-nadene.blogspot.com/2016/05/israels-military-versus-netanyahu-and.html
Update: 3/24/2020 Found: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2013/10/21/lydda-1948
Benny Morris, young Israeli historian on Lydda, https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2004-jan-26-oe-morris26-story.html
Messages From A Syrian Jew Trapped In Egypt, by Nadene Goldfoot 
Can't leave out Benny Morris, Israeli historian, born December 1948. He was a professor of history in the Middle East Studies department of Ben-Gurion University of the Negev in the city of Beersheba, Israel